Benjamin Hornigold – Painted Blood & Plunder Miniature Showcase

The 6th and final commander that was released as part of this year’s Summer of Plunder Campaign! Today we showcase Benjamin Hornigold!

Benjamin Hornigold Model

Another great sculpt from Daniel, lead sculptor at Firelock Games.

Unfortunately there are no period depictions of Benjamin Hornigold, Firelock worked with what was available, along with a little dose of influence from the depiction of Hornigold from Black Sails.

We think of Hornigold as “grandfather of the 18th century pirates,” but he wasn’t actually that old! He only lived to 38.

Our sculpt gives us a well dressed, serious looking Englishman sporting a tidy beard.

The miniature also seems to owe something to Jason Klotz’s excellent kitbash for Hornigold that we featured a couple years ago.

Benjamin Hornigold miniature, painted (front)

Who Was Benjamin Hornigold?

Hornigold was a influential privateer and pirate of the early 18th century who eventually took the king’s pardon and become a pirate hunter.

He helped found Nassau as a pirate haven and helped launch many famous pirate captains, including Blackbeard, Bellamy, and Bonnet. Hornigold hesitated to attack English ships which eventually led to him being replaced as captain of his ship by Samuel Bellamy.

By 1718, Hornigold would take the pardon offered to the pirates of Nassau and work with Woodes Rogers to actively repress the remaining pirates who were driven from Nassau. His ship was wrecked on a reef in 1719 and it is assumed he died in the wreck, although there were a few survivors.

You can read up on Hornigold in Colin Woodard’s The Republic of Pirates, or Angus Konstam’s The Pirate Menace.

Republic of Pirates book & B&P sloop

Benjamin Hornigold in Blood & Plunder

Hornigold is a strong commander that can be used by both the Pirates and English in Blood & Plunder.

Hornigold comes with the 3 Command Points you’d expect from a 30 cost commander combined with a 12″ Command Range. He’s armed with a Brace of Pistols and 4 Special Rules

  • Bold
  • Cold Blooded
  • Inspiring
  • God’s Blessing of the Devil’s Luck

The absence of Broadside! is notable, but that’s a great set of rules, especially for commanding a smaller ship that might focus on boarding.

Inspiring is a excellent utility rule that lets you reroll fails on Rally attempts he commanders. Cold Blooded is amazing on offense, giving his men bonuses on Shoot and Fight tests when attacking a unit that has more Fatigue than they do. God’s Blessing or the Devil’s Luck gives you that extra Fortune Point that twist fate in your favor. And Bold lets Hornigold give out Command Points as usual while he is engaged in melee combat which makes him great for leading and coordinating a boarding party.

Hornigold can lead the Golden Age Pirates, The Flying Gang, and British Privateers.

Leading the Flying Gang, his Cold Blooded is expanded to all units getting the Ruthless rule, and he gets Shallow Draft on all his ships, in addition to that free mulligan for activation cards, and the option for free Grapeshot. The only limiting factor is he can’t use a ship larger than size 2 in the Flying Gang.

The Golden Age Pirates are similar, except they might be drunk, and they can use larger ships.

He is particularly well suited to the British Privateers faction. Combining his Cold Blooded with the faction-wide Hard Chargers rule and the Brawlers rule you find on the Sea Dogs and Able Seamen can produce some insanely numbers when boarding an enemy ship.

Painting Benjamin Hornigold

I went with a conversative paint scheme, largely taken from the Black Sails portrayal of him.

Using a mix of Monument Hobbies and Citadel paints, I gave him a conservative blue coat with black trim, a gray waistcoat, and brown breeches and a plain black tricorn.

With black leathers a not a light of bright highlights, I think the paint job makes him look like a serious seamen.

Most depictions show him as an older man, but since he only lived until his late thirties, I decided to go really like with the gray hair, just adding a few highlights to the hair and beard.

The new method of sculpting for the eyes that Daniel used on this mini really worked for me! With minimal effort, the face and eyes came our really well. Great sculpting!

Somehow I got my Hornigold leaning forward a little more than he should on his base.

Perfect for putting on that back deck of the Bermuda Sloop! He’s just on his sea legs.

Dr. D’s Benjamin Hornigold

Dr. D painted up an entire set and gave them away during the Summer of Plunder this year.

Dr. D always does an amazing paint job!

I love the blue waistcoat under the brown coat! Beautiful paint job.

More Benjamin Hornigolds

Liam T painted up a great version of Hornigold with a touch of red.

Dan’s version has a little white in the hair!

And Riley’s is dark and brooding!

Benjamin Hornigold Scenario in The Summer of Plunder

The Summer of Plunder organized play kit included this Hornigold miniature and a scenario that features both him and Blackbeard.

This is a unique scenario in that it is designed for 3 players. Sometimes you have that game night where three people show up and it can be hard to make a balanced game with three. This scenario has two pirate players in sloops attempt to take down one large French merchant ship. If they attack piecemeal, it won’t go well. And stay out of the broadside path of that slow giant!

You and read through a battle report on this scenario below.

And we had a lot of people submit pictures of their games featuring Hornigold!

I believe Kurtis Fraley is running this scenario at Nova Open in early September this year!

You can find the 2026 Summer of Plunder scenario book that includes Hornigold and Teach’s attack on La Concordeon the Firelock Games Download page.

Here are some more pics of Hornigold in the light box.

And some shots of Hornigold on the job.

Final Thoughts

Thanks for Firelock Games for creating this great new sculpt for Benjamin Hornigold this year! The entire set of minis was a great addition to the 18th century part of Blood & Plunder this year!

The full 2026 SoP set of Commanders

You can still pick up the kit on Firelock Games’ website here.

You can find our showcase articles here on Blood & Pigment:

Article written and mini painted by Joseph Forster.

Special thanks to Dr D, Dan, Liam and Riley Faulk for sharing photos of their Hornigolds.

Leave a Reply